Jusletter IT

A preliminary study on the quantification of the normativity of the judicial precedent

  • Autoren/Autorinnen: Ferruccio Auletta / Francesco Romeo
  • Kategorie: Beiträge
  • Region: Italien
  • Rechtsgebiete: Rechtsdogmatik, Rechtstheorie
  • Sammlung: Tagungsband IRIS 2019
  • Zitiervorschlag: Ferruccio Auletta / Francesco Romeo, A preliminary study on the quantification of the normativity of the judicial precedent, in: Jusletter IT 21. Februar 2019
This work faces the need to scientifically measure and quantify the normative value of each new decision. The access to the Supreme Court, the constitutionally essential guarantee of the Italian justice system, now depends on the recognition of a «judgement» as a guiding principle. This rule raises the need for an appropriate measurement, which is therefore such as to assign a normative quotient with non-arbitrary criteria and which takes into account all the incident elements in the elaboration of the marginal normative range of the single decision. The work is based on and directed to legal systems in which (or in the extent of) the principle stare decisis does not apply, or is expressly forbidden as in the case of the French regulation of arrêts de règlement.

Table of contents

  • 1. Introduction
  • 2. Normativity and the need for measurement
  • 3. A theoretical starting point and parameters for a possible quantification
  • 4. Time and space of the precedent
  • 5. Disclaimer
  • 6. References

0 Kommentare

Es gibt noch keine Kommentare

Ihr Kommentar zu diesem Beitrag

AbonnentInnen dieser Zeitschrift können sich an der Diskussion beteiligen. Bitte loggen Sie sich ein, um Kommentare verfassen zu können.