de en
KURZBEITRÄGE

Can privacy impact assessment mitigate civil liability? A precautionary approach

Privacy impact assessment (PIA) is now considered an important tool to address privacy challenges of the digital era. Unless PIA is already mandatory, regulators need to provide incentive to both public and private sector to conduct PIA and thus potential limitation or even exclusion of civil liability seems attractive. In this paper, we try to understand why PIA can impact this liability by going back to its foundation, i.e. the precautionary principle. A good PIA could demonstrate no fault was committed or could allow resorting to the so-called development risk defence.


Table of contents

  • 1. Why this research?
  • 2. Going back to the roots of PIA: The precautionary principle
    • 2.1. Precaution – its origin and scope
    • 2.2. Precaution and civil liability: a renewed duty of care
  • 3. The development risk defence
    • 3.1. Higher standard of liability for dangerous activities
    • 3.2. Impact on liability
  • 4. Precaution, a nexus between strict and fault liability: the pivotal concept of development risk defence
  • 5. Can PIA mitigate civil liability?
    • 5.1. PIA – an implementation of precaution?
    • 5.2. PIA – mitigation or exclusion of liability?
  • 6. Conclusion
Please log in to read the full text.
Register for Campus? More
Login Poster
Handelskammer Deutschland-Schweiz
Jurist/in 50-60% Handelskammer Deutschland-Schweiz
Kantonspolizei Zürich
Jurist/-in 50 - 100 % Kantonspolizei Zürich
Advestra AG
Senior Associate/Counsel im Bereich [...] Advestra AG
BGPartner AG (Zürich)
Anwältin / Anwalt BGPartner AG (Zürich)
Niederer Kraft Frey AG
Rechtsanwältin / Rechtsanwalt 100% [...] Niederer Kraft Frey AG
Suter.Legal. AG
Anwältin / Anwalt mit Schwerpunkt [...] Suter.Legal. AG
Avolta
Senior Legal Counsel - Switzerland Avolta
/dam/jcr:d85df556-4302-43d6-aece-94d632ee9245/uni_li_logo.jpg
Intensivkurs «Internationales [...]
/dam/jcr:274399e0-95f5-417e-8939-fe54d7fbfc49/Uni_Basel_Recht_aktuell_Neues_Logo.webp
Recht aktuell-Tagung: «Aktuelle [...]
/dam/jcr:78d820ad-8ef9-4865-a1e9-bb678a9af215/Dike_logo.jpg
Schweizer Enforcement Tagung 2026
/dam/jcr:9971e878-ea1f-4b6a-9a70-e6475db5f185/Logo_verband_bernische_notare.jpg
Weiterbildungstagung: Das Notariat [...]
/dam/jcr:d85df556-4302-43d6-aece-94d632ee9245/uni_li_logo.jpg
Intensivkurs «Strafrecht und Unternehmen»
/dam/jcr:f3fc0eb9-f291-4e27-abdf-7b7a481595ef/Schulthess_Forum_rgb.svg
Strafprozessordnung 2026 Digitale [...]
/dam/jcr:83f09d58-4a62-41b1-9c9c-02abeb440d40
KI im juristischen Alltag - [...] Weblaw Academy
/dam/jcr:2e9579bd-bc09-4fea-a327-9cd7e3831be2/HSLU_Logo_DE_Schwarz.jpg
Fachkurs ChatGPT & Co. in der [...]
/dam/jcr:8a7f3354-213a-43de-a59d-a7475e221373
Rechtssicher mit KI - Kompaktseminar [...] Begrenzte Plätze.
/dam/jcr:0ed7ae66-e1c1-4249-9dea-27540e12da8d/unisg.webp
St.Galler Gesellschaftsrechtstag
/dam/jcr:b4a83ede-c2b1-42e7-b80f-60c5778d8901/ufl_logo.svg
Doktoratsstudium Rechtswissenschafte[...]
/dam/jcr:83f09d58-4a62-41b1-9c9c-02abeb440d40
Legal Prompt Engineering mit ChatGPT [...] Weblaw Academy
/dam/jcr:48e078d1-06c6-4c49-81c7-3704e8d9abf9/Uni_StGallen_irph_logo.webp
CAS Prozessführung – Civil Litigation
/dam/jcr:83f09d58-4a62-41b1-9c9c-02abeb440d40/academy.svg
AI für die juristische Praxis der [...]
/dam/jcr:83f09d58-4a62-41b1-9c9c-02abeb440d40
12. Weblaw Forum LegalTech - AI für [...] Weblaw Academy
/dam/jcr:274399e0-95f5-417e-8939-fe54d7fbfc49/Uni_Basel_Recht_aktuell_Neues_Logo.webp
Art & Law 2026
/dam/jcr:83f09d58-4a62-41b1-9c9c-02abeb440d40
«Prêts pour Justitia 4.0!?» - Cours [...] Weblaw Academy
/dam/jcr:83f09d58-4a62-41b1-9c9c-02abeb440d40
Online-Kurs: AI für die juristische [...] Weblaw Academy
/dam/jcr:d85df556-4302-43d6-aece-94d632ee9245/uni_li_logo.jpg
Intensivkurs „Strafrecht und [...]
/dam/jcr:2513d656-4f19-4079-ac7b-20994bb9e76e/uzh%20logo.webp
CAS Safety in Healthcare
/dam/jcr:8a7f3354-213a-43de-a59d-a7475e221373
Rechtssicher mit KI - Kompaktseminar [...] Begrenzte Plätze.
/dam/jcr:2e9579bd-bc09-4fea-a327-9cd7e3831be2/HSLU_Logo_DE_Schwarz.jpg
MAS Economic Crime Investigation
/dam/jcr:0ed7ae66-e1c1-4249-9dea-27540e12da8d/unisg.webp
St.Galler Arbeitsrechtstagung
/dam/jcr:d85df556-4302-43d6-aece-94d632ee9245/uni_li_logo.jpg
Executive Master of Laws (LL.M.) in [...]
/dam/jcr:c2a09a2e-ee26-4225-a6e7-2d9825723fad
CAS Compliance in Financial Services Institut für Rechtswissenschaft und [...]
/dam/jcr:48e078d1-06c6-4c49-81c7-3704e8d9abf9/Uni_StGallen_irph_logo.webp
CAS Haftpflicht- und Versicherungsrec[...]
/dam/jcr:d85df556-4302-43d6-aece-94d632ee9245/uni_li_logo.jpg
Executive Master of Laws (LL.M.) im [...]
/dam/jcr:274399e0-95f5-417e-8939-fe54d7fbfc49/Uni_Basel_Recht_aktuell_Neues_Logo.webp
Praxis im Baurecht
/dam/jcr:d85df556-4302-43d6-aece-94d632ee9245/uni_li_logo.jpg
Executive Master of Laws (LL.M.) im [...]
/dam/jcr:8b6df4d5-09f7-430b-ba5c-c0f8fa36cf22/Paulus_Schriftzug_positiv_CMYK.png
Tagung der Fachgruppe «Reform im [...]
/dam/jcr:2e9579bd-bc09-4fea-a327-9cd7e3831be2/HSLU_Logo_DE_Schwarz.jpg
MAS Information & Cyber Security
/dam/jcr:8a7f3354-213a-43de-a59d-a7475e221373
Rechtssicher mit KI - Kompaktsemina[...] Begrenzte Plätze.
/dam/jcr:2e9579bd-bc09-4fea-a327-9cd7e3831be2/HSLU_Logo_DE_Schwarz.jpg
CAS Data Protection & Technology